The Anatomy of a Useful AI Agent

The Anatomy of a Useful AI Agent

Creating AI agents that are genuinely transformative requires a deep understanding of their essential components. Let’s break down the anatomy of a truly useful AI agent.

1. Clear Purpose

A useful AI agent starts with a clear, well-defined purpose. Whether it’s automating a workflow, providing insights, or managing tasks, the agent’s role should be crystal clear.

2. Robust Data Access

An agent is only as good as the data it can access. Ensure your agent has robust, reliable data sources and can interpret that data effectively.

3. Contextual Awareness

Context is key. A truly useful agent understands the environment it’s operating in — whether it’s the workflow, the user’s preferences, or the business goals. This allows the agent to make more relevant and accurate decisions.

4. Does it remember, or learn?

People often describe an agent that remembers their preferences as one that “learns”. That’s not always wrong, but it blurs three mechanisms that work differently, have different owners, and fail in different ways.

A useful reference is CoALA, short for Cognitive Architectures for Language Agents (Sumers, Yao, Narasimhan and Griffiths, Transactions on Machine Learning Research, February 2024). Its section on learning treats writing information to an agent’s memory, so it can be retrieved into later prompts, as a different mechanism from adjusting the language model’s weights by fine-tuning, which it describes as a costly form of learning. CoALA calls both of them learning. So the point here isn’t that memory doesn’t count as learning. It’s that storing context and changing the model are separate things, and you should know which one your agent is doing.

Stored context

The agent writes information somewhere, such as a file or a database row, and later reads it back into what the model is given. In CoALA’s terms, that’s a memory update, not a change to the model’s weights.

Anthropic’s memory tool documentation is a concrete example. Claude asks for file operations such as create, view, or delete; the developer’s application carries them out against storage that application controls; and the memory lives in that application. The page describes storage and doesn’t discuss model training or weights. My reading that this kind of memory leaves the model untouched is an inference from the mechanism it describes, not something the page states. I also wouldn’t read anything about a vendor’s wider training or data-use policy into that silence.

What matters in practice: stored context can be wrong or go stale, and someone can inspect and delete it. Who that someone is depends on where it’s stored.

Feedback someone acts on

Collecting thumbs-downs, complaints, or flagged outputs doesn’t improve an agent by itself. Improvement happens when a named person or an explicit process looks at the failures, changes something (a prompt, a tool, a rule, or an evaluation), and then checks that the change helped without breaking something else.

Hamel Husain’s Your AI Product Needs Evals (March 2024) describes that kind of loop: keep looking at logged traces, write tests and assertions from the failures you find, and keep updating those tests as new failures show up. CoALA also counts changing an agent’s code, including its prompt templates, as a form of learning. Either way, someone has to own it. Without an owner, feedback is just a log.

When training happens

Changing a model’s weights is a deliberate process. Someone assembles suitable examples, runs fine-tuning or another training method, and evaluates the result. CoALA notes that because fine-tuning is costly, the studies it surveys schedule when learning happens. Using an agent doesn’t make it happen.

Whether a model provider uses your interactions to train its future models is a separate question again. That’s answered by the provider’s terms, not by whether your agent has memory. Nothing in this post assumes you need to train anything.

One preference, three ways

Here’s an illustrative example, not a real system. Take one preference: summaries should be short, five bullet points at most.

Stored contextFeedback someone acts onTraining
What happensA user says “keep summaries short”. The agent writes “prefers summaries of five bullets or fewer” to that user’s preferences file and reads it back at the start of later sessions.Reviewers flag several summaries as too long. The person who owns the agent reads the flagged examples, finds the prompt asks for “comprehensive” summaries, rewrites it, and adds an evaluation case that fails if a summary runs past five bullets. They rerun the evaluations before shipping.A team collects example documents paired with good short summaries and fine-tunes a model on them, then evaluates it.
What changesOne user’s stored file. The model is unchanged.The prompt and the evaluations, for every user. The model is unchanged.The model’s weights.
Who can undo itWhoever can edit or delete the file. If the user changes their mind and nobody updates the file, the agent keeps applying a stale preference.The prompt owner, by reverting the change.The team, by going back to the previous model.

The third column is a conceptual comparison only. For a preference this simple, the first two are cheaper to try and easier to reverse.

5. Autonomy with Boundaries

While autonomy is important, a truly useful agent also operates within defined boundaries. This ensures it doesn’t overstep or make decisions beyond its scope.

A component checklist

Use this to record what your agent actually has. Answer each line yes, no, unknown, or not applicable. Unknown is a legitimate answer, but it isn’t a capability: write down who could find out. Not applicable needs a reason.

AGENT COMPONENT CHECKLIST

Agent:
Completed by:                Date:

Answer: yes / no / unknown (who could find out?) / not applicable (why?)

1. STORED CONTEXT
   Does the agent store context between sessions?
   What does it store?
   Where does it live? (file, database, vendor service, other)
   Who can inspect it?
   Who can delete it, and how?
   How is stale or wrong context noticed and corrected?

2. FEEDBACK SOMEONE ACTS ON
   How is feedback collected?
   Who, or what process, reviews it?
   What can they change? (prompts, tools, rules, evaluations)
   How is a change checked before it ships?

3. TRAINING
   Has anyone deliberately trained or fine-tuned a model for this agent?
   If yes: who owns that model, and what examples were used?
   What do the model provider's terms say about using your
   interactions for training? (Read the terms; don't infer it
   from the agent's features.)

My editorial guess is that a first pass takes about ten minutes if you built the agent. That’s an estimate, not a measurement, and tracking down an unknown owner can take a lot longer. Those unknowns are the useful part.

These components are only half the picture. For how to test whether an agent is useful once it’s built, see what makes an AI agent actually useful. For what it takes to carry work through to an outcome, see designing agents that close loops, not just tasks.

Start with one question for an agent you use or build: where does its “memory” live, and who can delete it?

Glenn Gillen is a product leader, early-stage investor, and writer.

Want help turning ideas like these into reality? Let's talk.